Cat-owners should ignore a wildlife star’s advice to keep moggies indoors at night to protect mammals and birds, animal charities have said.

Autumnwatch presenter Chris Packham said that keeping cats indoors at night would halve the number of animals killed in Britain.

“Over 200 million animals are killed each year by cats. If you keep them in at night it reduces by 50 per cent,” Chris told the Radio Times.

He added: “If you put an electronic bleeper on them when they’re out during the daytime, it can reduce bird predation by 45 per cent.

“I love cats. I think they are beautiful, a wonderful predator. But what’s the point of feeding birds in the garden if you’re feeding them to your cat?” Chris added.

However the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB) said AG readers should not banish cats from gardens.

“Our policy on cats is clear. It is one of responsible pet ownership,” said a spokesman. “Research has shown that fitting cats with bells lowers the number of bird attacks.”

The Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (RSPCA) said there was no “perfect” way to deal with the problem of cats and birds. It claimed that research found that cats with loud tinkling bells caught 41 per cent fewer birds and 34 per cent fewer mammals.

The RSPCA backed RSPB advice to keep cats indoors only when birds are most vulnerable: at least an hour before sunset and an hour after sunrise, especially during March to July and December to January – as well as after bad weather, to allow birds to come out and feed.

Spokeswoman Helen Coen said cats are active animals, and advised anyone thinking of keeping theirs indoors to give it plenty of items to play with.

  • Evie

    I agree with Chris. I also believe that cat owners should keep their cats in at night. The cat population is un-naturally high. Feral cats live from 3-5 years, where as the domestic cat can live 20+ years. They do their most killing at dawn and dusk. But as well as keeping the killing of song birds and long nosed shrews down, it also keeps the cats safe as at dusk is also the time when most cats could be killed on the road.

    Oh, I should mention, I have 2 cats.

  • Ruth Janes

    I own a cat called Tommy. We have always kept him in at night, and as far as I am aware he has never been seen disturbing the local bird population, or have we had any dead ones presented to us, as this is his usual habit. He kills various rodents, which we don’t mind as they reproduce several times a year, and it stops them from eating our chickens food. (Incedentally, I have seen one of our chickens kill a mouse, so cats are not the only predators)!